Roth IRA Calculator — Roth vs. Traditional After-Tax Growth.
Model decades of tax-free Roth IRA compounding side-by-side against a Traditional IRA (including optional reinvested tax deductions), inflation adjustment, and 4% rule retirement income.
Scenarios:
·
After-Tax Retirement Verdict (35 Years · Nominal Dollars)
Roth IRA wins by $17,726
Tax-free compounding and zero withdrawal tax outweigh the upfront deduction.
Roth IRA (Tax-Free)0% withdrawal tax
$1,349,276
4% Rule Income: $4,498/mo
Traditional IRA (After-Tax)18% withdrawal tax
$1,331,551
4% Rule Income: $4,439/mo · incl. $225,144 side fund
After-Tax Balance Trajectory (Age 30 → 65)
Roth IRA Traditional Contributed
ROTH VS. TRADITIONAL PLAYBOOK
How taxes now vs. taxes later decide the Roth vs. Traditional winner.
1. The Core Tax-Rate Rule
If your marginal tax rate today is lower than your expected rate in retirement, paying tax now via a Roth IRA is mathematically superior. If you are in peak earning years and expect a lower retirement bracket, a Traditional IRA can come out ahead—especially if you invest the upfront tax savings.
2. Why Maxing Out Favors Roth
Because both accounts share the same annual dollar cap ($7,000 / $8,000 for 50+), filling a Roth IRA shelters 100% after-tax money, whereas a Traditional IRA’s balance still carries an embedded future tax bill.
3. Nominal vs. Real Purchasing Power
A $1,000,000 balance 35 years from now feels impressive, but 2.5% annual inflation cuts its real buying power to roughly $421,000 in today’s dollars. Toggle inflation-adjusted dollars to plan realistic living expenses.
Original contributions withdrawable tax- & penalty-free anytime
10% early withdrawal penalty + income tax before 59½
Required Minimum Distributions
None for original owner
Required starting at age 73
Frequently Asked Questions
When is a Roth IRA better than a Traditional IRA?
A Roth IRA generally wins when your tax rate in retirement is equal to or higher than your current marginal tax bracket—or when you max out the annual dollar limit, since $7,000 of post-tax Roth dollars effectively shelters more purchasing power than $7,000 of pre-tax Traditional dollars.
Why does the calculator include "Reinvest Traditional upfront tax savings"?
Contributing $7,000 to a Traditional IRA in the 22% bracket saves $1,540 in federal taxes today, whereas a Roth IRA requires paying that tax upfront. Reinvesting those tax savings in a taxable brokerage account creates a fair, apples-to-apples comparison of total after-tax retirement wealth.
What are the standard IRA annual contribution limits?
For individuals under age 50, the annual IRA contribution limit is $7,000 (use the $7,000 Max preset), and savers age 50 and older qualify for an extra $1,000 catch-up contribution ($8,000 total). Always verify current IRS income phase-outs for your filing status.
Do Roth IRAs have Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs)?
No. Original owners of a Roth IRA are never subject to Required Minimum Distributions during their lifetime, allowing investments to compound tax-free indefinitely—unlike Traditional IRAs, which require RMDs starting at age 73.
What does "today’s inflation-adjusted dollars" mean?
Nominal dollars show the raw future account balance on your statement decades from now. Enabling inflation adjustment discounts that future number by your inflation rate so you can see what that balance will actually buy in today’s purchasing power.
How is the 4% Rule monthly retirement income calculated?
The 4% rule multiplies your final after-tax retirement balance by 4% and divides by 12 months—a widely used benchmark for sustainable 30-year retirement withdrawals.