Guide

THE TOOLBOX / HOME FINANCE & MAINTENANCE

Repair vs. Replace Calculator —
Appliance 50% Rule, Lifespan Benchmarks & ENERGY STAR Savings.

Should you fix that broken fridge, washer, dishwasher, or AC unit—or buy new? Compare repair quotes against remaining lifespan, the 50% rule, and 5-year ENERGY STAR utility savings.

50% Rule & Value VerdictRECOMMENDED: REPLACE
Repair / New %
33%
50% threshold
Lifespan Used
62%
~5.0 yrs left
5-Yr Energy Save
$375
w/ new unit
Replacing makes stronger financial sense: the repair represents a steep share of a new unit’s price given the appliance’s remaining useful life and warranty.

APPLIANCE DECISIONS

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the 50% rule for repairing vs. replacing an appliance?

Consumer Reports’ classic 50% rule states that if an appliance is more than halfway through its expected lifespan AND the repair quote exceeds 50% of the cost of a brand-new replacement, you should replace it rather than repair it.

What is the average lifespan of major home appliances?

Typical lifespans are: Dishwashers (9 yrs), Water Heaters (10 yrs), Washing Machines (11 yrs), Dryers (12 yrs), Refrigerators (13 yrs), and Ranges / Central HVAC systems (15 yrs).

Should energy savings factor into replacing an old refrigerator or HVAC?

Yes. A 12-year-old refrigerator or central AC uses significantly more electricity than a modern ENERGY STAR unit—saving $75 to $350+ per year on utility bills and effectively lowering the net cost of replacing.