Guide

THE TOOLBOX / OPEN ENROLLMENT & BENEFITS

HDHP vs. PPO Calculator —
Compare Total Health Plan Cost, HSA Tax Savings & Break-Even Curve.

Compare an HDHP + HSA against a traditional PPO side-by-side across healthy, moderate, and catastrophic medical years—accounting for premiums, deductibles, coinsurance, employer HSA seed money, and tax savings.

Medical Spend:
$3,200
$0 (Preventive Only)$10,000$25,000+
HDHP + HSA Plan
Traditional PPO Plan
HDHP + HSA Wins at This Spend LevelAt $3,200 billed care
Save $2,731/ year with HDHP + HSA
HDHP + HSA Net Cost
$1,569
Prem $1,380 + Care $2,240 − HSA $2,051
PPO Net Cost
$4,300
Prem $3,180 + Care $1,120

Total Net Cost Curve ($0 – $25k Billed Care)

HDHP + HSAPPO
$0k$2k$3k$5k$7k$0k$5k$10k$15k$20k$25k

4-Scenario Annual Cost Stress Test

Healthcare YearHDHP NetPPO NetWinner
Healthy ($500)-$171$3,680HDHP (-$3,851)
Moderate ($3,500)$1,629$4,360HDHP (-$2,731)
Major Event ($12,000)$3,329$6,060HDHP (-$2,731)
Catastrophic ($35,000)$3,829$6,680HDHP (-$2,851)

IRS HDHP & HSA THRESHOLDS

2025 & 2026 IRS HDHP & HSA Limits at a Glance.

IRS Rule2025 Self-Only2025 Family2026 Self-Only2026 Family
Max HSA Contribution$4,300$8,550$4,400$8,750
Minimum HDHP Deductible$1,650$3,300$1,700$3,400
Max HDHP Out-of-Pocket$8,300$16,600$8,500$17,000
Age 55+ Catch-Up+$1,000+$1,000+$1,000+$1,000

1. How True Net Plan Cost Is Calculated

HDHP Net Cost = (Monthly Premium × 12) + Out-of-Pocket Care − Employer HSA Seed − (Employee HSA × Effective Tax Rate). For the PPO, Net Cost = (Monthly Premium × 12) + Out-of-Pocket Care. Remember that preventive annual physicals and screenings are $0 under both plans.

2. Worked Open Enrollment Example

Suppose an individual HDHP costs $115/mo ($1,380/yr) with a $2,000 deductible and $750 employer HSA seed, while the PPO costs $265/mo ($3,180/yr) with a $600 deductible. Even before investing the HSA, the HDHP starts $2,550 ahead in guaranteed savings plus over $1,200 in payroll/income tax savings when maxing out the HSA.

4. Modeling Notes & Privacy

This comparator models in-network deductible and coinsurance structures. If your PPO uses flat copays that bypass the deductible for frequent prescriptions or therapy, adjust the PPO deductible downward to approximate your real out-of-pocket spend. All inputs stay private in your browser.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the IRS HSA contribution limits for 2025 and 2026?

For 2025, the IRS HSA contribution limit is $4,300 for self-only HDHP coverage and $8,550 for family coverage. For 2026, the limit rises to $4,400 for self-only coverage and $8,750 for family coverage. Individuals age 55 or older can contribute an extra $1,000 catch-up amount. Employer HSA contributions count toward these combined limits.

Why does an HDHP + HSA often win even in a catastrophic medical year?

In a catastrophic year where you hit your out-of-pocket maximum on either plan, your true worst-case cost is Annual Premiums + Out-of-Pocket Max − Employer HSA Seed − HSA Tax Savings. Because PPO premiums are often $1,800–$4,500 higher per year than HDHP premiums, the HDHP frequently has a lower worst-case ceiling than the PPO.

When is a PPO better than an HDHP?

A PPO typically wins when you have predictable, moderate annual healthcare usage (often $2,000–$5,000) where PPO copays and a lower deductible shield you from paying full negotiated rates, AND the premium gap between the PPO and HDHP is small, OR if you do not have emergency cash to cover an unexpected deductible early in the year.

How does the HSA triple tax advantage work?

HSA contributions made through employer payroll avoid federal income tax, most state income taxes (except CA and NJ), and 7.65% FICA payroll taxes; investments inside the HSA grow tax-free; and withdrawals for qualified medical expenses are 100% tax-free—with no "use-it-or-lose-it" deadline.

Does this HDHP vs PPO calculator send my health or salary data anywhere?

No. Everything runs 100% client-side in your browser. Your premiums, deductibles, HSA contributions, and medical spending estimates remain completely private on your device.