Guide

THE TOOLBOX / KITCHEN & COOKWARE

Cast Iron Pan Guide —
Skillet Sizes (#3–#14), Cooking Area & Seasoning Smoke-Point Chart.

Compare cast iron and carbon steel skillet floor area and quart capacity side by side, decode vintage stove numbers, and pick the best seasoning oil and oven temperature.

Smoke Point: 420°F · Oven Bake: 450°F (60 min)
Top Pick — hard, dark, non-flaking polymerization
Cooking Area & Volume ComparisonPan B has +37% floor area
Skillet A · #8 (10.25")
60 sq in
~2.5 qt (2.3 L) · 2–4 people

Daily workhorse: 2 steaks, roast chicken thighs, skillet pizza

Skillet B · #10 (12")
83 sq in
~3.8 qt (3.6 L) · 4–6 people

Family dinners, 3–4 pork chops, whole spatchcock chicken

Seasoning Rule: Wipe oil on, then wipe it off with a clean paper towel until the pan looks completely dry—too much oil creates a sticky, splotchy polymer.

SKILLET QUICK CHART

Cast Iron Skillet Numbers, Diameters & Ideal Servings.

Vintage #Top RimFlat FloorServings
#58.0"~33 sq in1–2 people
#810.25"~60 sq in2–4 people
#1012.0"~82 sq in4–6 people
#1213.25"~104 sq in6+ people

Frequently Asked Questions

Should I buy a 10.25-inch (#8) or 12-inch (#10) cast iron skillet first?

A 10.25-inch (#8) skillet is lighter, easier to handle one-handed, and ideal for 1–3 people. A 12-inch (#10) skillet provides ~37% more flat cooking floor area—making it much better for families of 4+, searing multiple steaks without crowding, or roasting a whole chicken.

What do vintage cast iron skillet numbers (#3, #5, #8, #10) mean?

Old stove-eye numbers (#3 through #14) originally matched the circular burner openings on 19th-century wood-burning cookstoves. A #8 corresponds to ~10.25"–10.5", a #10 to ~11.75"–12", and a #5 to ~8".

What is the best oil and oven temperature for seasoning cast iron or carbon steel?

Grapeseed oil (420°F smoke point) and canola oil (400°F) are the most reliable everyday seasoning oils. Rub an ultra-thin layer onto a warm pan, wipe off every visible trace, and bake upside down at 450°F for 60 minutes, then let cool inside the oven.

Can I use dish soap on a seasoned cast iron skillet?

Yes—modern mild dish soap does not contain lye and will not strip true polymerized seasoning. Simply wash promptly, towel dry immediately, warm on the stove for 1 minute to evaporate moisture, and wipe with a drop of oil.